Beyond The Body
  • Home
  • About
  • Contributors
  • Contact

The Goldwater Rule - How It's Stirring Up More Controversy With The Upcoming American Presidential Election

8/14/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Since 1973 the American Psychiatric Association have abided by the "Goldwater Rule", which states that it is unethical for psychiatrists to diagnose or offer a professional comment on a public figure's mental status when they have not personally evaluated the individual. The rule was created following the 1964 presidential election in which a magazine had published a survey in which thousands of psychiatrists commented on wether candidate Senator Barry Goldwater was psychologically fit for presidency. 

With the US election in full force and many individuals commenting on the presidential candidates, most notably Donald Trump, again the APA has reminded its members to keep the Goldwater Rule in mind. However, this year some psychiatrists and mental health experts are challenging the Goldwater Rule; some say its for the better good of the nation, while others report that having such in-depth access to candidates nowadays they have greater and stronger information with which to base their opinions on.

"Supporters of the Goldwater Rule have cited three main rationales for adhering to it: Most diagnoses made from a distance turn out to be wrong; the labels themselves can cause real harm to the person and family members; and the practice undermines the field’s credibility, particularly its commitment to confidentiality. Not to mention, others say, that it could expose a left-leaning bias in the field...

But those using clinical language to describe Mr. Trump’s behavior contend that this presidential election is vastly different, for a big reason: The proliferation of social media comments and video clips, which afford direct, unscripted access to candidates, was simply not available in previous races. The depth of that material creates a public persona complete enough to analyze on its own merits, they say."


What are your thoughts on the Goldwater Rule? How do you think mental health professionals should respond when asked their opinions on public figures or presidential candidates mental health?

For the full article, click here:
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/16/health/analyzing-donald-trump-psychology.html?emc=eta1&_r=1


1 Comment

Choosing Wisely Canada - Psychiatry Recommendations

11/3/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
As part of the Choosing Wisely Canada campaign, in June, 13 recommendations were made by the Canadian Psychiatric Association and its working group partners, the @Canadian Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (CACAP) and the Canadian Academy of Geriatric Psychiatry (CAGP) for the field of ‪‎psychiatry‬.

One of the main recommendations included how first-line treatments for ‪‎insomnia‬ should not include routine use of antipsychotics, and rather should be focused on non-pharmacological options including sleep hygiene and behavioural techniques.

Other recommendations also comment on treatments for ‪ADHD‬, ‪depression‬, and ‪‎dementia‬, as well as on using benzodiazepines in acute care, and ordering toxicology screens on psychiatric patients. For the full list check out the link here: http://www.cpa-apc.org/media.php?mid=2240


1 Comment

Practice The Art Of The Mental Status Examination

10/28/2015

1 Comment

 
The Mental Status Examination is a vital part of any psychiatric assessment or encounter with patients with possible ‪mental health‬ concerns. To brush-up on your observation skills and the components of an MSE, check out these short and helpful videos that walk you through formulating a MSE during three different patient encounters!
1 Comment

At The CPA: A Discussion Around Physician Assisted Death

10/3/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
As we posted about previously, there is a great deal of ongoing discussion surrounding the recent Supreme Court ruling that struck down the ban that prohibited physician-assisted death (PAD). At the Canadian Psychiatric Association, health reporter Andre Picard moderated a discussion among the psychiatry and palliative care communities and asked "Are We Ready?"

Key points of the talks included:
  • 29% of Canadian doctors would participate in PAD.
  • 50% of patients in palliative care have a mental health disorder
  • Evidence showed that PAD actually leads to increased utilization of palliative care.
  • Some argued that there is no slippery slope, and in countries/states already employing PAD, the right to dying with dignity has not been abused
  • Many psychiatrists are concerned about finding the right balance between enabling death with dignity, while protecting patients from suicide and self-harm.
  • Most palliative care physicians do not want to be involved in PAD.
  • In Oregon, 1/3 of patients requesting PAD, never use the prescribed medication, but patients want to have the option of having control over their final days.
  • Language is crucial, not only for setting guidelines or criteria for who has the right to die, but also in how we describe and refer to PAD as. Is a term such as "physician hastened death" preferable to "physician assisted suicide"?

What do you think about PAD? How do you think it will influence certain healthcare providers and their patients?


1 Comment

Psychiatry and Physician-Assisted Suicide

9/22/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
As you may remember, a few months ago, the Supreme Court of Canada made history when they unanimously struck down the ban that prohibited physician-assisted death for adults suffering "grievous" and "irremediable" conditions. While many applauded the decision in favour of personal autonomy and approved of Canadian citizens having the right to decide whether they wish to die with dignity or not, within the field of psychiatry hesitation and concern still lingers ...

Specifically, many psychiatrists are worried about how the new ruling will affect patients with mental health conditions, as they fear many would argue that certain mental illnesses cause "intolerable suffering" and treatments are often used for symptom control rather than a definite cure, making it fit under the "irremediable" criteria as well.

What's more is that some are arguing that psychiatric assessments should be performed for every person seeking assisted death, which could place psychiatrists in more of a "gatekeeper role" and in a immensely difficult position trying to balance between "enabling" suicide/death while still trying to protect patients, particularly those with mental illness‬.

To learn more about what psychiatrists from around the country are saying about this topic, check out the interesting article here: http://news.nationalpost.com/health/0914-na-suicide

"The ruling is creating deep discomfort in a field of medicine where “cures” are rare, and where many worry there is every possibility severe depression and other mental illnesses could meet the test for assisted suicide, or even euthanasia — death by lethal injection — as set out by the court, as long as the person is competent and can provide free and informed consent...

The big fear for psychiatrists is that they may be participating in physician-assisted death, when there is a chance for treatment."



1 Comment

Good Reads: The Death of Small Creatures

4/30/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
Trisha Cull is a well-published writer and poet from British Columbia.  Though initially known for her writing and poetic art, Trisha recently released her memoir The Death of Small Creatures, that powerfully depicts a part of her life many did not appreciate before.  In this haunting and powerful novel, Cull describes her struggles and battles with bulimia, bipolar disorder, and substance use.  While the book is thought by readers to be confusing at times, it details the reality that many individuals with mental illness face day in and day out, struggling with feelings of hopelessness, helplessness, and ultimately vulnerability.

Recommended For:
Those interested in psychiatry or wanting to see mental illness from a firsthand perspective 


Read More
1 Comment

Psych In The News - Week 57

4/12/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
Catch up with all the news related to mental health and psychiatry from last week!

Read More
1 Comment

Technology's Impact on Psychiatric Medicine

4/8/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
While the use of technology has been largely beneficial, including in the medical profession, there are some drawbacks to society's increasing reliance on things like the internet as many physicians will point out often mentioning their frustrations over how frequently patients are now self-diagnosing by using Dr. Google.

From the psychiatry stand point, as psychiatrist Anna Fels from Weill Cornell Medical College points out in the article "Do You Google Your Shrink?", the internet has led the field to change and evolve as we never would have predicted. In her article, she examines the ways in which technology has been both a help and a hindrance within the world of psychiatric medicine.

"I knew my psychiatric practice was forever changed the day a patient arrived with a manila folder stuffed with printouts and announced that it contained the contents of a Google search that he had done on me. He pulled out a photo of my mother and me, age 7, that had been published in my hometown newspaper; architectural plans for an addition to my house that was never built but apparently was registered locally by the architect; an announcement about my great-grandfather’s becoming editor of Amazing Stories magazine in his old age; and my brother’s history as a college activist...

IN some ways, the relentless electronic interconnectivity of our lives serves to highlight therapy’s singular virtues. We are more appreciative of the strange, private dialogue that is the heart of ‪#‎therapy‬. There are precious few times and spaces left in our society in which people quietly speak to one another in a sustained, intimate conversation. The therapist’s office is one of the last safe places. Secrets, reflections, fears or confusion never leave the room."



1 Comment

The Stigma Surrounding Psychiatry

3/19/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
While on her psychiatry‬ rotation, med student‬ Natalie Wilcox, experienced first hand the stigma that surrounds psychiatric diagnoses. However, not only did she see how stigma affects patients, but she noticed that it also affects medical students and health professionals in the way they treat patients with addictions and mental illnesses, as well as the way they view and value the psychiatry profession.  Read more here: "Psychiatry is Devalued: And Patients Suffer Because of It".

"Instantly the man straightened up, “So you think it’s the ‘D word?’ I really don’t want that diagnosis.” I had never heard of depression referred to as the “D word,” but it definitely struck a chord with me. This man was so uncomfortable with the idea of being associated with a mental health diagnosis that he couldn’t say the name. At one facility where I rotated, psychiatric services were hidden in a corridor known as “behavioral health.” Patients with diagnosed mental health issues saw “stress management” workers, a title intended to disguise psychologists and psychiatrists.

How can patients be expected to feel comfortable with a psychiatric diagnosis if clinics themselves refuse to identify the services as such? Such euphemistic doublespeak only serves to undermine the progress made in psychiatric care and reinforce the stereotypes associated with mental illness and its methods of treatment."



1 Comment

Increased Need For Safety Measures in Hospitals

12/9/2014

1 Comment

 
Picture
A physician was recently injured by a patient during a psychiatric assessment in Penticton, British Columbia (find out more here). While we should remind ourselves that majority of psychiatric patients are not violent, this story does however bring to attention the need for enhanced security measures in hospitals to help maintain the safety of both patients and healthcare providers.


1 Comment
<<Previous

    Description

    Supporting and enhancing students' and health professionals' knowledge and understanding of mental health and psychiatry

    Archives

    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    Aboriginal Mental Health
    Abuse
    Addiction
    ADHD
    Advocacy
    Agitation
    Alcohol
    Alcohol Withdrawal
    All
    Alzheimer's Disease
    Animals
    Antipsychotic
    Anxiety
    App
    Art
    Autism Spectrum
    Awareness
    Barriers To Care
    Bereavement
    BIID
    Bipolar
    Books
    Borderline
    BPSD
    Caregivers
    Catatonia
    CBT
    Child Psychiatry
    Complicated Grief
    Concussion
    CPA
    Cultural Psychiatry
    Delirium
    Dementia
    Depression
    Dermatillomania
    Diagnosis
    Documentary
    DSM 5
    Dual Diagnosis
    Eating Disorders
    ECT
    Education
    Educational Resource
    Epilepsy
    Ethics
    Exercise
    Factitious Disorder
    Film
    Food
    Forensic Psychiatry
    Gambling
    Gaming Addiction
    Gender Dysphoria
    Geriatric Psychiatry
    Global Mental Health
    Harm Reduction
    Heart Attack
    Hoarding Disorder
    Humanities
    Infographic
    Initiatives
    IPad
    Language
    Law
    LGBTQ
    Loneliness
    Malingering
    Mania
    Medication
    Meditation
    Mens Mental Health
    Mental Health
    Mental Health Law
    Mental Status Exam
    Military
    Mind-body Wellness
    Mindfulness
    Mood Disorder
    Music
    Neurodevelopmental
    Neuropsychiatry
    News
    Ocd
    Panic Disorder
    Parksinson's Disease
    Patient Perspective
    PDD
    Personality Disorders
    Phobia
    Physical Health
    Physician Suicide
    Physician Wellness
    Poems
    Pop Culture
    Postpartum
    PPD
    Prevention
    Psych Assessment
    Psychiatry
    Psychoanalysis
    Psychosis
    Psychotherapy
    Ptsd
    Recovery
    Refugee Mental Health
    Relationships
    Reproductive Mental Health
    Research
    Resiliency
    Safety
    Schizoaffective Disorder
    Schizophrenia
    Screening
    Seasonal-affective-disorder
    Selective Mutism
    Self Harm
    Self-harm
    Ses
    Sexual Disorders
    Sleep Disorder
    Social Anxiety
    Social Isolation
    Social Media
    Somatic Symptoms And Disorders
    Sports
    Stigma
    Stress
    Stress Injury
    Student Mental Health
    Substance Use
    Suicide
    Surgery
    Technology
    TED
    Therapy
    Tools
    Transgender Mental Health
    Treatment
    Trichotillomania
    Womens Mental Health
    Youth

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.